As other law schools laxed grading, U. Chicago Law School passed on 'pass fail'

  • The dean of the University of Chicago law school refused to move to pass/fail grading amid the coronavirus outbreak.
  • He referenced the school's core values, including the “seriousness of our education."

The University of Chicago Law school refused to let students take advantage of a lax grading system, while other American law schools lowered standards amid the initial clamor of the coronavirus outbreak. University of Chicago Law School Dean Tom Miles informed students via email that there would be no changes to their current grading system for the spring 2020 term. 

Miles added, “We will continue to assess information as it arrives and remain prepared to make a change if warranted.” Miles emphasized the “core values” of the college, including the “seriousness of our education,” and noted that he intended for the law school’s approach to be in line with these values. 

"If all law schools abolished grades, our weaker students would develop a false sense of security"   

[RELATED: Law profs who oppose relaxed grading 'less likely' to say so publicly, prof says]

He went on to explain that because of the school’s unique academic calendar, UCLS was “unusually well situated to rise to the occasion.”

“Unlike most other law schools, next week we will start a new quarter. These classes will start anew rather than having been disrupted as semester-long courses were at other schools, and they come after an opportunity for a break and adjustment,” wrote Miles.

“Our faculty, who are already the best legal educators in the world, have had weeks, not days, to prepare for remote teaching. There are sure to be a few hiccups and stumbles, but I am confident that overall classes will run well in our new system. I am confident in our faculty’s ability to provide excellent teaching as they always do, just as I am confident that all of you will put as much effort into your learning as you always do.”

As Campus Reform previously reported, constitutional law professor Josh Blackman recently wrote an op-ed for Reason, condemning the practice of switching to lax grading policies for future lawyers: "Attorneys have a duty to their clients during crises of all manners; law students should learn that lesson personally...any sort of grading relief should be tailored to address individual circumstances; law schools should not adopt a blanket policy,” said Blackman.

[RELATED: 'No Fail Yale': Ivy League lowers academic expectations amid coronavirus]

"If all law schools abolished grades, our weaker students would develop a false sense of security: well, I passed, and didn't fail, so I must be okay! ... The students at the top and middle of the class will be fine. But the students who would most benefit from getting a bad grade will not receive the help they so need, and deserve," Blackman added. 



STAY INFORMED
Get exclusive access to breaking CampusReform stories as they happen. Sign up below and we'll keep you in the loop.
 Weekly Digest

 Daily Emails

Francisco Moreno and Celine Ryan
Francisco Moreno | California Campus Correspondent

Francisco Moreno is a California Campus Correspondent, reporting liberal bias and abuse on campus for Campus Reform. He studies Spanish at Southwestern College in Chula Vista. In his spare time, Francisco volunteers as an intake specialist with a non-profit serving the homeless.

20 Latest Articles